Penny Tracey

My name is Penny S. Tracey and I am proud to represent First American Title-Indiana as a Business Development Executive. I am committed to provide you with superior service along with the very best products and services in the business.

I am able to provide this level of service directly from over 23 years of experience in the title insurance and real estate industry.  I am very focused on providing an excellent experience for all parties involved on every single transaction and give my absolute best to what I do. I am extremely passionate about building and maintaining personal and professional relationships. We have ONE common goal in mind: Getting to the closing table! Let me be the problem solver to the problems you didn’t even know you had.

I am an active member of MIBOR and have sat on various committees through the years. I’m also a proud graduate of the Class of 2019 REAL (Real Estate Academy of Leadership). Through this I am able to combine my personal and professional goals in life in bettering our community and providing strength and commitment thru education and volunteering!

You can count of me to provide you with the highest level of personalized service that will ensure peace of mind for you, your homebuyers and sellers as well as the professionals that serve in the transaction. I am a valuable resource and one more reason you can depend on First American Title.

Specialties: Title Insurance, Escrow, Closings, REO, Relocation, Short Sales, Purchase, Refinance, Closing Costs, 1031 Exchange, Investment, Commercial, Real Estate, Residential

What is Title Insurance? (Video)


Service Area

Areas of Service: Boone County, Delaware County, Hamilton County, Hancock County, Hendricks County, Johnson County, Madison County, Marion County, Montgomery County
First American Title
350 Westfield Road
Suite 200
Noblesville, IN 46060
Get Driving Directions

Helpful Links

Below are a selection of links that I think you will find useful. Please note that some of these links are to third-party websites and First American cannot guarantee the accuracy of content contained on third-party sites.


Was this page helpful?
Thanks for the info!
Share Contact us

Give Feedback

  • Issues with a First American Product or Service
    • Home Warranty
      • Tell Us About Your Experience
      • Start a Claim
      • Request a Quote
    • Title Insurance, Escrow or Settlement Services
      • Tell Us About Your Experience
      • Submit a Claim
    • Home Insurance
      • Tell Us About Your Experience
      • Start a Claim
  • Issues with a First American Website
    • Reset a Password
      • FASTWeb
      • myFirstAm
      • AgentNet
    • Report a Website Problem